After a long night in the labor and delivery unit, Shirley Bashore enters the Mercy Hospital chapel to have a moment of prayer, but she immediately discovers that the bronze cross that hangs above the altar is missing! Shirley is devastated. Even above its monetary worth, the cross carries sentimental value in the community for the patients, visitors, and employees of Mercy, so Shirley decides to track down the thief. Meanwhile, Shirley and her friends are tasked with pulling together the Memories on the Harbor exhibit, a look back at Mercy’s history, and a reception to honor some of its most well-loved retirees. And all the while, her heart is rapidly thawing for a certain hospital administrator. Can she put her faith in God’s timing and trust that He will help her find the cross—and learn to love again?