Cassie is back and full of surprises! Will her Bishop father send her packing right back to where she came from when he sees she has disobeyed his orders? Wanting to stay but unable to support herself without help from her family and the community, she enlists the help of the matchmaker. Will Sadie be able to help her, or will Cassie have to make a tough and devastating choice for her future? Meanwhile, Benjamin Schrock, Libby's brother, has more than his fair share of troubles and wants to visit the matchmaker to make him a match, but he just can't seem to get his own life straight, and can't see making a new bride suffer along with him!