Miracles happen at Christmas! Suspend what you think is real and come on an Amish journey with Heidi. Heidi King was one woman who needed a miracle. She left the Amish community years ago and built a life for herself as a successful New York City realtor. Loneliness and regret cause her to cry out to God. Heidi wakes the next morning to the life she would've had if she'd stayed in the Amish community and married Derek, her old Amish love. At first, she was delighted to be Derek's wife and mother to their three children, but soon motherhood and the realities of life in the Amish community overwhelm her. Heidi finds her way back to her city life and her single status. Now with no children and no Derek, will she realize she's made the biggest mistake of her life? Will Heidi be able to find her way back in time for an Amish Christmas?

Many said Matt Yoder was the most handsome Amish bachelor in the county, maybe even the country. When he contacted Jane and asked her to return to the community where she grew up, she was convinced all her prayers had been answered. She'd always dreamed of marrying Matt and having a large family. Her dream turned into a nightmare when she discovered he asked her to come home to help him select a bride. He was tired of being single and declared he would be married by Christmas. He had narrowed his search to five women and was having trouble deciding between them. Since Matt had always overlooked Jane, was it already too late? Or can she find a way to make him see that she is and always has been his perfect Amish match?

She's Amish, and he's an Englisher. Matt and Alice are thrust together when Matt's sister and brother-in-law pass away, leaving behind their baby girl. Matt and Alice are two drastically different individuals who must decide which one of them is better placed to adopt the baby. When snowflakes are swirling outside, presents under the tree, and laughter ringing through the air, can these two rivals put aside their differences for the sake of the child? This Christmas, could all their prayers be answered?