Cate, Heather, and Rae Bellarose move back home to Cave River, Arizona to fulfill the terms of their grandfather’s will to work together for one year in their family’s cafe and cat rescue. If they succeed, they get a big pile of money. If they fail, they go back to their regular lives, no worse off. This should be a breeze. Cate is determined to make it work, whatever it takes. Too much money is at stake. Off the bat, things are beyond strange. She keeps seeing impossibilities that she can’t explain. Floating feather dusters, lights that aren’t there. Then, all the plants in town die. Something is way off. Cate and her sisters discover an ancient book in a hidden room in the family’s mansion. That’s when things really get weird. Suddenly, Cate has powers! So do her sisters, daughter, nieces, and aunts! Also, some insane warlock is trying to buy the whole town and that sends up red flags in all directions. The sisters need to find out why and how to stop him or they might lose the money before they get a chance to inherit it.

Heather Bellarose is happier than she has been in a long time. Returning to Cave River, Arizona, and reconnecting with her sisters has filled a void she hasn’t realized she’s been missing. However, nothing is ever perfect. Her sixteen-year-old daughter doesn’t like her for moving them away from Seattle. Then Brady, Heather's ex, moves to Cave River, stirring up all kinds of mixed emotions. Their relationship is complicated at best. Heather isn’t sure she can trust him not to leave her again. Nothing can be simple, especially when the boarding house burns down, and Brady has to stay at the Bellarose mansion. Heather puts him in the farthest room from hers, of course. The evil warlock who is set on buying up the whole town is causing chaos. Cate is cursed, and Heather and Rae work to break it all the while running the cat cafe and fulfilling their duties outlined in their grandfather’s will. Losing her heart to her ex-husband for the second time isn’t the only thing Heather has to worry about. She and her sisters must save the entire town.

Rae is the baby of the family. The only thing she’s good at is avoiding responsibility. But when she’s forced to come home, her daughter shows up, and she has to share a house with her sisters, everything changes. Then, things get worse. There’s a curse on her family, and her sisters go missing. Rae is suddenly responsible for a household full of people, trying to break the curse, and having to follow the clues to her sisters’ whereabouts. On her search, she meets a handsome police officer who steals her heart in a way no man has before. But after a lifetime of poor choices, she's determined fight for her feelings and stays focused. Only, what if it’s not enough? What if evil warlocks and confusing spells destroy Rae’s confidence and stop her from rescuing her sisters? Hopefully not, or the town might not survive the loss of the three powerful sisters.