As the first glorious days of summer reach Lancaster, Maine, Jan makes an unsettling discovery while cleaning out the storage unit containing her late mother’s effects. A nondescript manila folder reveals decades’ worth of faded newspaper clippings about a baby who was taken from a Portland hospital—on the very day Jan was born there. What was behind her mother’s obsession with this baby, whose name—Jane—was so close to Jan’s? Meanwhile, as the cousins uncover clues about their chandelier’s path from the mysterious abandoned mansion across the lake and its journey to the tearoom, Elaine’s son, Jared, arrives with his family at the tearoom for an all-too-rare visit from Ohio, and Jan’s daughter Amy confides a life-changing secret to her that she hasn’t yet told anyone else.