Written as part of Kris 'n' Good Books' 'choose your own m/m story' challenge. This is now hosted by Goodreads' M/M Romance Group.
The story prompts for the author were:
the setting ~ a convention
some background to the main protags ~ it's their first meeting
another character ~ a half nekkid cowboy
a conflict ~ pineapple
a piercing or tattoo ~ a My Little Pony tattoo
an object to be mentioned in the story somewhere ~ a jock strap