Newly minted private investigator Ronan O’Mara is working tirelessly to make his detective agency successful. When he’s asked to look into the suspected suicide of a local psychic, he quickly realizes there’s been a murder. A second psychic is found dead in her kitchen days later, and Ronan begins searching for clues to connect the two crimes. Worried he is in the line of fire, psychic Tennyson Grimm is running scared. With no leads and few clues, they are no closer to finding the monster stalking the psychic community. After speaking with clients of the deceased psychics, Ten realizes they were con artists, duping their clients into spending every last dime they have to reunite with lost loved ones and break curses. When someone close to Tennyson is attacked and nearly killed, the psychic community rushes to West Side Magick, hoping Ten and Ronan can find the killer and stop him before he strikes again. The pieces of the puzzle fall into place for Ronan when the next body drops. Now, it’s a race against time to get to the killer before he gets to Tennyson.