Wendy Wreath is a witch from the small town of Moon Hollow. Never married, she’s been called a spinster. But really, she’s just more interested in flying fast on her broomstick and solving random mysteries than becoming someone’s wife. Plus, she has her hands full running her store, Wicked Wendy’s Décor, where she sells her own magically created holiday decorations. For the tenth year in a row, Wendy is put in charge of overseeing the sales of her coven’s apple pies at the annual Autumn Equinox bake sale. The fruity baked goods are award-winning, and it's a great honor to be asked. But when the high priestess of a rival coven is found murdered near Wendy’s station, she’s picked as the prime suspect. Thorin Sands is the new sheriff in town. He’s tall, dark, and ferociously handsome. Immediately he seems to have something against Wendy and does everything in his power to prove she is the killer. Wendy’s long-time beau does his best to protect her, but even he is no match for the overbearing lawman. When Wendy discovers Thorin’s secret, everything changes, and she must make a choice. Mercy or vengeance. She isn't sure what to do but she must decide before another witch dies. Can Wendy solve the case before the unreasonably gorgeous Thorin makes her pay for a crime she didn't commit?