Joey is at a New Years Eve party, sulking in heart break from a recent breakup. Just when he thinks it couldn't get worse, Dillon, an old bully from high school, enters his life again. Short story, one night stand.

A week after New Year's Eve, Joey believes he will never see the man who took away his pain again. He's had time to think too, and realized that his relationship with his ex wasn't all that great either. However, just when he thinks he's in the clear, a familiar face comes around, asking for a second chance. Sequel to Once Upon A New Year's Eve.