Amber Wakefield traveled to Hunter’s Grove, Kansas to meet her intended and walked into a very unwelcoming atmosphere. Charles Turner, her intended, seemed cool and aloof. His brother Garrett—down right rude. She wants nothing more than to rush back to Virginia, but Edna Smith, her chaperone, falls ill, and she's forced to stay. She knows Charles harbors a secret, and she isn't sure whether Garrett is her hero or her enemy. When she finally discovers the truth, she wants nothing to do with either of them. One of the brothers vows to win her love. Which one?

ABIGAIL LIVINGSTON arrives in Hunter’s Grove to marry Scotty McCabe and discovers he was shot and killed just days before her arrival. Determined to find the murderer, she finds herself butting heads with the impossible constable, Cole Johnson. COLE JOHNSON, livery owner, finds himself as acting constable after Constable McCabe is shot. When McCabe’s mail order bride arrives, he finds her bold and overbearing. He vows to avoid her at all costs. Yet, despite their instant dislike for each other, they work together to find the killer. They discover while investigating, they might actually like each other.

Graham Easton sends for a mail order bride, but when she arrives, he changes the rules they’d agreed upon in their correspondence. Unknown to her is, he has an ulterior motive for bringing her to Hunter’s Grove. He stalls the nuptials by saying they need to get to know each other first, and invites her to live with his family in the meantime. Grace Webster arrives to meet the man she’s to marry, and discovers he’s much older than she’d thought. He has grown children, and a four-year-old granddaughter. When her groom changes their plans, she becomes confused and angry. She wonders why he brought her there, and for what purpose.