All fourteen-year-old Orthodox Jew, Leah Kaplan, has ever wanted was to be popular. When her best friend Chavy accidentally upsets the queen bee, the popular girls are out for revenge. Once they discover that Chavy has a crush on Leah’s brother, they come up with a plan—to pretend to be him online and cause Chavy to fall in love with him. Then they’ll humiliate her by telling her the truth. They choose the prefect person to carry out the plan: Leah. Hoping to remain on their good side, she agrees. Chavy Diamond has always worried she’d lose her best friend to the popular girls. When it happens, she finds solace in an unlikely person, Leah’s brother. The two of them grow close and Chavy opens up about her difficult home life. Even though she knows she’s not allowed to have any kind of relationship with a boy, she finds herself falling for him. Things are spiraling way out of control and Leah knows it’s time to ditch the popular girls and come clean. But will Chavy find it in her heart to forgive her, or is their friendship gone forever?

Chavy Diamond and Leah Kaplan’s friendship ended when Chavy left to Florida to start over. Now she’s back for college in New York and is determined not to let the past hold her back from living her life. But that’s not easy. Everywhere she turns, she’s reminded of what happened five years ago. As if that’s not enough, she meets the one person she never wanted to see again—Leah’s brother, Avi. Maybe coming back wasn’t such a good idea. Leah has never gotten over the guilt for causing her former best so much pain years ago. Unhappy with her life, she lashes out at all those trying to help her. When she learns Chavy is back, she tells herself the best thing to do is stay out of her way. All that changes when Avi urges her to try to reconnect with Chavy, something Leah has wanted since the day Chavy left. Can the two of them let go of the past and embrace a new future as friends?