Six years have passed since that fateful night when Ella's actions cost the life of her beau's father and twin brother. Now, she must return home for her brother's funeral and face seeing her former beau again. Will she finally find peace or will returning home be one of the biggest mistakes she has made in her young life?

Three years have past since Faith Graber abandoned her newborn daughter on her parent's doorstep. Now she has returned to the Amish community she was so anxious to leave. Can she trust the Lord to heal her broken heart? Her new found faith is put to the test as she finds that sometimes when you love someone, you have to let them go.

Gideon Wyse is surprised when he returns to his childhood home and finds it occupied by a beautiful dark haired woman. After an accident at his job damaged his sight, he had planned to return LaGrange County to nurse his wounds, not be forced to deal with a stranger. Can the Lord heal his heart and show him that he needs the love of his family and friends or will he reject their concern and continue with a life on his own, no matter how lonely.

Holly Graber has spent most of her adult life watching friend after friend marry and start families of their own. Will it ever be her turn? An unexpected move to Daviess County opens up a whole new world. Will she find love among the rolling hills of southern Indiana? Or will she be forced to spend the rest of her life heartbroken and alone.

Will Rose choose to follow the path the Lord intends for her? Or will she decide to jump the fence and experience life outside of her community? Will the love of one man be enough to get her to stay and realize that there is nothing quite like family, faith and home?