Margins
My Argument with the Gestapo book cover
My Argument with the Gestapo
1975
First Published
3.48
Average Rating
260
Number of Pages

Here, for the first time in print, is Thomas Merton’s only existing pre-monastic prose work, a novel written before he entered a Trappist monastery. One earlier novel, written at about the same time (1939-1941), was destroyed by the author but he had always felt that My Argument with the Gestapo still represented his views on peace and war and he wanted to see this book published. It had already been scheduled for 1969 publication before he met his untimely death on December 10th, 1968. The novel is the story of a young man, told in the first person, who returns to England from America in order to cover the war in Europe from a poet’s viewpoint. This visit did not in fact take place, but as the young Merton moves around in London at the height of the World War II blitz; spends nights in the London subway with hundreds who use the underground stations as a bomb shelter; visits an elderly foreign lady who may or may not be a spy; is interrogated by the Allies and by the Gestapo in France, he recalls his earlier days in Europe. In the description of his school and college days the reader will find scenes that later appeared in somewhat different forms in The Seven Storey Mountain, Merton’s first published prose work, his autobiography that became an international best seller when it was published in 1949. There is a dreamlike—or nightmarish—quality to the story, heightened by the use of a weird composite language, a mixture of English and several foreign tongues, in which the young narrator converses with the old lady and her entourage, and with his notes. Hence the novel’s sub-title, A Macaronic Journal . Here then is the youthful Merton, asserting his abhorrence for war, which he re-affirmed in his more mature works. It is a picture of the full horror of war and its degradation of human existence, frighteningly real and beyond control, as apt today as when it was written.

Avg Rating
3.48
Number of Ratings
29
5 STARS
14%
4 STARS
41%
3 STARS
28%
2 STARS
14%
1 STARS
3%
goodreads

Author

Thomas Merton
Thomas Merton
Author · 90 books
Thomas Merton (1915-1968) was one of the most influential Catholic authors of the 20th century. A Trappist monk of the Abbey of Our Lady of Gethsemani, in the American state of Kentucky, Merton was an acclaimed Catholic spiritual writer, poet, author and social activist. Merton wrote over 60 books, scores of essays and reviews, and is the ongoing subject of many biographies. Merton was also a proponent of inter-religious dialogue, engaging in spiritual dialogues with the Dalai Lama XIV, Thich Nhat Hanh, D. T. Suzuki and poet Robert Lax. His life and career were suddenly cut short at age 53, when he was electrocuted stepping out of his bath.
548 Market St PMB 65688, San Francisco California 94104-5401 USA
© 2025 Paratext Inc. All rights reserved