It has to be him. Sabrina Madden has held to that belief since her separation from Frankie, her first love. After aging out of their group home six years ago, she, Frankie, and Aaron stayed by each other’s side. Until Frankie’s addiction got the best of him and destroyed the family they’ve built. The fallout forced her to make a choice, staying with Aaron when he kicked Frankie from their lives on the promise that she and Frankie would talk in secret until they could be together again. Sabrina sees an opportunity for a reunion when Oliver Holcomb asks her to be his date to his brother’s wedding—one state over from where Frankie is living now. Oliver, the rugged and ruly, bearded mechanic who’s had his sights set on Sabrina since the moment he started working at Aaron’s shop, sees this trip as an opportunity to mend his relationship with his brother, strained by their mother’s death, and to finally have Sabrina for his own. Sabrina’s heart has never failed her, but now, for a second time, she’s being forced to make a choice. Feelings she’s refused to accept, because it has to be Frankie, are breaking the surface—for Oliver, testing everything she believes about love. What if the one it has to be isn’t always the one? What is the price of finding out?