Mitchell Farraday and Rachel Moore are perfect for one another. The only problem is the chances of the two of them ever meeting, let alone falling in love, are non-existent. However, fate is on their side in the form of a witch named Sadie Sutton. She’s been assigned to the Department of Love, and with her new match-makin service Perfect Pairing, Mitchell and Rachel are not only destined to become lovers but soul mates for eternity.

What happens when someone has humiliated you on public television? And how do you deal with a woman who has thrown a martini in your face and brought the press along to witness it? If you’re Evie Winters and Kyle Daley, you despise one another. However, Sadie Sutton, witch and CEO of Perfect Pairing knows better. She’s taking a gamble on the future of her matchmaking business, determined that these two are a match made in heaven. She’ll do anything to get them together even if it means trapping them in an elevator that’s about to get stuck between floors and feeding Evie the most potent aphrodisiac known to witches…

Jake Harris’ world fell apart when his wife passed away. Now a young widower, he vows to never give his heart to another woman. However, Army buddy, Mitchell Farraday, thinks a gift certificate to Perfect Pairing is just what he needs. Vowing he won’t use it, he throws it in the garbage bin. However, Jake has second thoughts when strange things begin happening, convincing him that his late wife wants him to use it. Gen Thompson, a single mom, hasn’t been out of a date in over two years. When an ad for a free membership to the Perfect Pairing mysteriously appears in her local newspaper, she decides to take the plunge. Perfect Pairing CEO, and everyone’s favorite matchmaking witch Sadie Sutton, knows she has her work cut out for her this time. Can Jake ever get over his heartbreak, and can Sadie make him see that Gen is his destiny?

Lucy Davis has always loved Bryce but never told him as much. She’s even signed on with Perfect Pairing in hopes they can finally be a couple. However, one day Lucy picks up the newspaper and sees that Bryce is now married. With her heart broken, she goes to see Sadie Sutton, president of Perfect Pairing, to tell her she won’t need their matchmaking services. Sadie’s convinced that the universe has other plans for Lucy, including a man who will sweep her off her feet. Brad Ryan finds a baby sitting on the doorstep of his sheriff’s office. If that isn’t a big enough surprise, he discovers a note tucked into the baby carrier informing him he’s the daddy. What’s a sheriff to do when he’s suddenly thrown into the role of single father? Sadie might have the answer and it’s in the shape of a nanny called Lucy. Will these two fall in love, and will Sadie have another successful pairing to gloat about?

Luc Frasier lost his sight in a bomb attack while on active duty in the army. His buddy Jake, who now trains service dogs, offers him a German Shepherd who he thinks will make the ideal companion. Jake also thinks he needs a woman to heal his heart and thinks one of his dog trainers, Katey Hopkins, is the girl for the job. He knows Luc won’t go along with the idea so he enlists the help of Sadie Sutton, witch and president of Perfect Pairing, to bring the two together. As always, it’s not an easy task for Sadie. Luc’s stubborn and Katey’s a shy virgin. But Sadie hasn’t failed yet and she’s determined that Luc and Katey will be another one of her success stories.

Cole True hates the holiday season because he lost his wife two weeks before Christmas. He’s vowed never to decorate another Christmas tree or even so much as look at another woman. However, when his sisters decide to buy him a gift certificate for Perfect Pairing, he knows he has a fight on his hands. Hayley Ward runs Rustic Inn, a quaint B&B that’s lacking one thing, paying guests. When Sadie Sutton, president of Perfect Pairing spends some time there she knows she’s found the ideal mate for Cole. With a little coaxing, and as always a little magic spell here and there, she encourages Hayley to go look for a Christmas tree in the very lot that Cole is manning one snowy night.

Gabriel Miller wanted one thing, for his younger brother to come safely home from his latest deployment while serving as a Marine. When Mavis White tells him she’ll grant him that wish in exchange for her turning him into a wolf-shifter, he takes it, thinking she’s drunk and playing a joke on him. However, Mavis is a rogue witch and soon Gabriel finds himself naked in the canyon with no recollection of how he got there. Sadie Sutton’s been given the task of finding Gabriel, and finding him true love through her Perfect Pairing agency. Amber Maxwell is losing her sight and decides she wants to find the man of her dreams while she’s still able to see his face. Can Sadie bring together two people who are both in transitions in their lives and give them a happy ending or will Mavis White spoil the day?