Everything changed the night Jessica disappeared. Lives ruined. Futures destroyed. Hearts shattered. Ten years have gone by, and Jessica's best friend, Rowan, is finally getting things back on track. But when a lost child turns up in town, Rowan is certain the kid is connected to the girl who never came home a decade ago. Rowan seeks help from some old friends, hoping to reopen the investigation into the mysterious disappearance. It's too bad nobody believes her.

As Rowan and Logan set out to find answers about Jessica’s disappearance, a photo from the past brings new revelations that can’t be ignored. Tyler comes up with a plan that puts his career on the line while trying to help Rowan, but when Ms. Opal extends the olive branch, new findings change everything.

While Rowan and Tyler seek answers about the children’s marks, they learn things that lead to an impossible profile of their abductor. With the child advocate granting special counseling for the children, things are looking up. But when a strange couple shows up at Ms. Opal’s place, Rowan believes the children are in grave danger. Convincing everyone else is the problem as Tyler deals with a new prisoner, and Logan, his family crisis. Rowan is determined her instincts are stronger than ever. She’s been right so far, but will her luck run out?

When Tyler takes Rowan to a meeting with the children and their counselors, a vicious attack takes them off guard. While Ava is taken by three strange men, Tyler finds himself in the crosshairs, and Xavier runs for his life. As the FBI takes over, Tyler’s father is out for revenge, and willing to grant Logan a favor. With one of his children returning, and a man down, Alden pushes Benny to investigate Lilac’s involvement with Wayne Greene, but when past secrets come to light, all bets are off.

Now that Rowan, Logan, and Tyler have found the location of the Seekers of Eden compound, they set out to find out what’s going on behind the garden wall. But when their elaborate plan fails, the consequences of their actions could be fatal.

Rowan's decade-long search for her missing friend ends up with her being kidnapped and held prisoner by a sadistic cult. Her friends set out to save her, but they can't do it alone. They'll have to convince law enforcement to join the fight. When cult leader Alden Adams orders another deadly attack, it's only a matter of time before all hell breaks loose and paradise burns. Will Rowan's friends breach the walls before her demise, or will an unlikely hero save the day?