It was not their first trip to Siren Falls. It was their last. Distant from her husband, Warren, and estranged from her peer group, Claire cannot bear to tell anyone that she got fired. The loss of her job, however, is forgotten when Warren suggests a reunion weekend with their college friends Michael and Dani. The weekend, like many before it, is to be spent at their shared cabin in Siren Falls, northern Michigan. On their first morning, they wake to find a warning, painted in red, written on an interior wall of the Eyes that wander, Loyalties that For these sins, I come as your bane. Despite resistance from her husband and friends, Claire decides to investigate the warning. When her prime suspect goes missing, however, Claire is forced to reassess. The police officer assigned to them sheds minimal light on Claire’s missing suspect and orders them to remain in Siren Falls. Trapped together, secrets begin rising to the surface, threatening the last of Claire’s stability. She begins to wonder if she ever knew her husband or friends. As Claire struggles to press on and dredge up rusty talents, the situation pivots with a kidnapping and a stunning confession. With what appears to be a supernatural stalker closing in, Claire fights to understand why they are being hunted before she becomes another of its silent victims.