Laura is nursing a broken heart while on vacation in a seaside resort town. She was supposed to be there on her honeymoon, but she's alone. Two things are making Laura feel better: ice cream, and the young man who serves it to her, Shawn. Shawn is trying to forget someone, an ex-girlfriend, only she won't let him. Laura and Shawn bond over their relationship problems and discover that when they're together, they seem to have no problems at all. Except for his ex, of course.

Laura returns home to Columbus, Ohio, and tries to resume her life. Her honeymoon is over, but at least she has someone new: Princess, the rescue dog. Princess finds a new friend at the dog park: Duke. He has pale blue eyes. Just like his doggy-daddy. Laura's not sure if she should go on a relationship diet, or if she should indulge by sampling every flavor of dating. Things are about to get very tasty.

First the dognapping, and now Lars shows up to be the hero? What the heck is happening in Laura's life? Can she get away with the justifiable crime of taking care of Sharise? In this third and final story in The Ice Cream Shop Boy trilogy, Laura spends some quality time with her two ice cream boys, Shawn and Zach. Summer turns to Fall, then Winter, and who will she choose to snuggle up with next to a flickering fire? Will it just be Laura and her beloved mutt Princess, together forever? Story #3 of a 3-story series.