Sophia Randall had no intention on returning to her home in the polygamist community she grew up when she left Hiram Jefferson just hours before their wedding. Though she cared deeply for Hiram and his family, she was young and impulsive. Ten years, two children, and one monogamous marriage later, returning to Green Valley after the death of her husband is the only option left. Hiram was devastated when Sophia left him at the altar. With everything already on his plate—between his job as the district superintendent, his large family, and one sick wife, the last thing he needs is the headache of Sophia being back in town. When his wives go behind his back and form an alliance with Sophia, what is left for him to do but show them the error of their ways with a little old fashioned discipline. But what will happen when he finds out the true reason Sophia left him in the first place?