One memorable Halloween Turnip, a rabbit, finds a hat and decides with the help of her animal friends, to keep it. But the hat's owner is a witch, and she needs it back to protect her cat friend, Pudding. The witch and Pudding hunt for the hat and find Turnip and demand it back but the animals invoke the woodland lore of 'Finders Keepers' and call a woodland court to determine who should have the hat. At the court we discover that the hat speaks, and it tells of being stuffed with magic and used as a cushion and poked with pins. Outraged the court decides Turnip should keep the hat. That night, after a long talk, Turnip and the hat decide the hat should return to the witch on condition that it is treated well. The witch is so grateful she invites Turnip to become her apprentice. The story celebrates friendship, compassion, and discovering one's inner magic.