The unexpected death of future Hall of Fame musician Tell Garrison, left struggling music report Jack Neil with more questions than answers. 25 years earlier an apparent conman that bore a startling resemblance to Tell had filed a lawsuit. He claimed that Tell was a con artist and fraud. Roddy swore he was the real Tell Garrison and entitled to the royalties from his music. Looking into Roddy's claims after Tell's death, leaves Jack wondering if the real Tell Garrison is going to his grave. What if there were actually two men living different parts of Tell's very public life, before and after his time in rehab? Is Roddy a deeply troubled soul or a man that had everything including his name taken from him? Was Tell a gifted musician, loving husband and dad, or a monster that condemned another man to eternal limbo by stealing his name? Jack doesn't simply want to know, he needs to know. He thinks the public has a right to the truth too. Powerful music industry executive Shay Bennett doesn't want that ugly history revisited. She wants to protect her family and the memory of the man she loved. Jack's wife fears Shay will ruin what is left of his career. What worries Jack is the increasingly unstable Roddy wants answers from Shay too. After the death of Roddy's lawyer and break in at Tell's psychiatrist's office Jack wonders if he should leave the past buried with Tell.