Emilia Scott is a psychology student at Watertown University who has just finished her junior year. The first three years of her college experience weren’t all that, as she was solely focused on her GPA, internships and working to support herself.However, with a great GPA, her graduate school applications lined up and only one year of college left she finally wants to finish the little list she made for herself in high school and there’s a green-eyed prince charming ready to help. Liam Mills, captain of the baseball team, has been ignoring the nagging little voice in his brain thathas had him questioning his life decisions for the better part of a year. He has to stay focused on baseball; it's the one thing he’s been dedicated to his whole life. Making it to the major leagues isn’t just for himself, it’s also to fulfill his promise to his dad. The only problem is his heart isn’t in it anymore and seeing a specific blue-eyed beauty with passion in hers makes him come face to face with the thoughts he’s been pushing away for months.

Eliza Mills has gone through a lot in the past few years. Her boyfriend dumping her? Check. Her best friend ghosting her? Check. Getting sick and eventually diagnosed with celiac disease? Check. Despite everything her hopeless romantic heart stays firmly intact. Eliza is excited for her fresh start as she transfers into Watertown University her junior year with a space of her own. There’s only one problem - a roommate she never expected. Garrett Moore is determined to never fall in love. After a rocky upbringing he believes it’s the safest path for him in life and so far, so good. As his senior year starts he finds himself in a surprising living situation and despite his new roommate being incredibly gorgeous, kind and somewhat sassy, the NHL bound hockey star refuses to let that phase him. His plan is going well until one day he sees her looking uncomfortable on campus and he ends up claiming her as his own. The two decide to form a mutually beneficial, fake, relationship but what happens when the line between what’s fake and what’s real gets blurred?