A rescue in need of cash. A broken heart in need of mending. Giving up and going back to work as an attorney didn't appeal to Jay, even though he knew it would bring in money to save his failing rescue, 2 Hearts Ranch. When Cody shows up after walking out on him too many years ago, Jay wonders if his former lover is playing a trick on him, or if Cody's arrival answers more than one of his prayers. Tired of not being accepted for who he was—a gay man—Cody walked away from his family's fortune to go after the man he loved—Jay. When he hears about the rescue's financial troubles, he knows he can help. Except some wounds take longer than others to heal, and he has to prove to Jay that this time, he's going to stay.

Jude returned to Wyoming looking reunite with his former lover Payton. A chance to play a cowboy at the 2 Hearts Rescue holiday event brought him face to face with...Santa? Underneath that costume, Payton was as hot as ever and when a tiny stray shows up on Patyon's doorstep, Jude realizes he has a ready made family. If only he could convince Payton that he's back for good.