Christmas is coming to Romance, Oregon...but for Andy McKay, it's only a reminder of the day the love of his life walked away. Guilted into playing Scrooge as a young man in the town's production of A Christmas Carol, Andy unexpectedly finds himself acting alongside his girlfriend of romance past. Cassie Winston has spent the past year traveling, writing, and regretting that she left the man she loved behind her. She’s afraid the old adage about how you can never go home again might be true. It’s hard enough to convince Andy to consider giving them a second chance, and acting with him in Scrooge and Belle's breakup scene certainly doesn't help. As ghosts from the past resurface, can they find a way to create a new future together?