Chelsea is used to burying her feelings for her two best friends, Henry and Ben, to protect her heart and keep from losing the two people she cares most for in this world. Now that they are back, she is finding it harder and harder to keep her attraction for them a secret. Ben and Henry foolishly kept Chelsea at a distance because of a stupid pact they made in high school. With old feelings flooding back, they are struggling with sticking to the pact. Why should they have to choose between their friendship and Chelsea, when they can both give Chelsea the world. Ben and Henry have just one night to convince Chelsea how good they can be for her.