Matthew wants to know more about his beautiful neighbor, and Sarah wonders if she could love again. Sarah Stoltzfus is the last of her siblings left unmarried after the man she loved chose to marry her younger sister. Meanwhile, after living among the Englisch, Matthew Miller is back in the community helping out on his uncle's farm. A chance meeting at a farm stand leads both Matthew and Sarah to dream of something more. The bishop and elders still mistrust Matthew after his time away, and he is forbidden to pursue marriage. Sarah's father feels the same way, being extra-protective of his heartbroken daughter. When Sarah's sister and her husband move back home, Sarah must confront the source of her pain. At the same time, a person from Matthew's Englisch life reappears, and the rumors begin. Matthew and Sarah must convince the others—and themselves—that they belong together before mistrust and gossip separate them forever. This sweet tale from Annie's Attic's Hearts of Amish Country series is a must-read for those who love stories of faith, friendship, and wholesome romance.