Living in the small stagecoach stop near Waterhole, Texas hasn't allowed Rosie to meet any eligble men, so she takes matters into her own hands and decides to send for a Mail Order Husband. However, on the day he is supposed to arrive, the stagecoach is held up. Rosie ends up with a stagecoach robber for a fiancé and an extra surprise she didn't expect. Will God be able to clear his name and help Rosie trust him?