Daniel Shelter’s arrival into Jamesville is tarnished by an unexpected and unprovoked savage attack. His 'angel', Bethlehem Berkey, has secretly been watching him from afar and thankfully comes to his aid before tragedy darkens the whole Amish community. Fear grips the people of Jamesville while Daniel’s attacker freely roams their unspoiled haven. A chance meeting finally reveals hidden secrets buried in Daniel’s past that have come to haunt him and ruin his new beginning. Will his attacker ever be caught? Will his shameful past prevent him from obtaining the affection of Bethlehem or can he explain all to his loving Amish angel?