Sarah, Emma, and Martha are the Bontrager sisters. Eli, Emma's beloved husband, is dead. She has to start to build a new life without him. As Emma struggles to cope with her grief, someone from her past makes a return into her life. Martha is still missing - will her sisters ever see her again? Meanwhile, Sarah has to cope with her ever expanding family and the rumors that are flying about the community...rumors that focus on her sister and a certain, married, Englischer.