Can Colin, the wayward brother, find his way back to the Amish and will Sarah be safe when she takes the baby to see its family? Colin Phillips is back in Philadelphia looking for the woman he loves. He has to tell her that she is welcome in Faith’s Creek along with her Friend Emma and her baby. Only, before he can tell her, disaster strikes, and Sarah’s life is changed forever. Sarah has fallen for Colin but she knows his brother will never accept her, especially now she has a baby. She decides to leave, hoping that Colin will go home and forget her. It seems the best choice for everyone, even though it breaks her heart. Can Sarah find safety and new hope while keeping baby Angela safe? Will Colin forget her, or will he search and push his family further away? Can the Phillips brothers finally be together and happy or is Colin destined to leave the Amish forever?