Katherine Sullivan and her sisters are desperate when they are not approved by any matchmaking agency in Boston. That is until matchmaker Tara Reed overhears their dilemma and offers them the chance to head to Nevada as mail-order brides. All they have to do is catch the train in the morning, but after an altercation with their landlord, Katherine knocks the man unconscious. Now they’re on the run to catch that train before the landlord finds them. Amos Bart and his brothers have been outlaws since they can remember, roaming Nevada robbing stagecoaches. That is until they decided to end their life of crime and settle down with the help of a mail-order bride. It doesn’t matter if the brides are not approved—neither are the grooms. Katherine and Amos each have a secret, but will it tear them apart, or throw them headlong into each other’s arms?

Mail-order bride Bonnie Sullivan has so many other things on her besides marrying Lucas Goodwin. She vows that no man will ever quash her spirit or control her, although in 1878 it's a wife's duty to cook and clean and raise a family. What she didn't count on when she married the once-outlaw Lucas was how complicated life could be, not only for her but the entire town of Yerington, Nevada. Lucas Bart and his brothers roam the Nevada trails robbing stagecoaches. That is until they change their last name and forgo their lives as outlaws in favor of settling down and raising a family. 
What Lucas wasn't prepared for was marrying a feisty mail-order bride. Bonnie Sullivan has a way of getting under his skin with her unconventional views of what a woman's role in a marriage should be. Lucas is more than ready for the challenge, but will they be able to find love when events in Yerington spiral out of control?