Amish Christmas Baby, Grace Fisher, is all grown up and due to marry Seth Yoder. But when she stumbles across the red and white stocking cap her mamm dressed her in to drop her onto Ellie Fisher's doorstep that Christmas morning after she was born, her mother is forced to share the truth surrounding her birth and how she'd come to be in this world. Shocked, Grace flees the community intending to visit her Aunt Sadie who lives in the city. It is there that she meets an unlikely Englischer who thinks she has all the answers that will solve all of Grace’s problems. But will her suggestions ruin the only life Grace has ever known?