Does Flannery stand a chance of winning this year's holiday baking contest and the heart of the man she loves, when her main competition for both is her most bitter rival? Flannery White is convinced that the way to a man’s heart is through his stomach. And if she has her way, she’ll be engaged to Divine, Colorado’s most eligible bachelor, Warren Kane, by the time Christmas Day arrives. The plan is simple. She’ll enter the town’s Christmas baking competition, impress him with her recreation of his favorite dessert, and find herself suddenly engaged to the object of her affections. The only problem? Flannery is a disaster in the kitchen. And to make matters worse, her rival, Stella, seems to be determined to win both the baking contest and Warren's heart for herself. Thankfully, Flannery’s best friend in the whole world, Sam Jolly, is ready to help her. As the son of a grocer, Sam knows his ingredients and his way around the kitchen. However, Sam's been keeping a little secret - he’s been head-over-heels in love with Flannery since they were children. Will Sam be able to put aside his love for Flannery to see her happily engaged to another man? Or will Flannery discover that true love might wear a flour-covered apron instead of an expensive suit?