When Rose Ebersol returns unexpectedly to her Amish community, she rekindles feelings with a handsome widower. After Rose Ebersol learns that her father is ill, she leaves the city and heads back to her Amish roots. Rose expects her father to still be angry with her, but she is hurt by the unexpected bitterness of Jonathan, her former best friend. Jonathan Fisher never forgot Rose or how she left. Her return rattles the widower, but now raising three children on his own and running his farm, he doesn't have time to reconcile the past. When Rose so easily slips into the role of caregiver for his children, Jonathan struggles not to get reattached to this woman who has always held his heart. Spending time with Jonathan's family and learning how to live a plain life again stirs a longing in Rose she didn't anticipate. Time will tell if she can gain the forgiveness—and the courage—she needs to return home for good.