It's Christmas Eve and Penny can't figure out what to get her coven sisters as gifts. Luckily, Turkey has an idea that will save the day. When the ladies find out that the annual town holiday party will take place up at the Terra Mansion, they decide to exchange gifts there. A trip to the wine cellar leads them to a locked and secret room. What's inside? And will Penny's crush, Max, be home for the holidays? This short story is a Hillcrest Witch Mystery special!