Dinah Capshaw prays every morning that she will fall out of love with Eli Brice. It's been five years, and each day, God answers her prayer a little more. She said goodbye to a man who loved her because he rejected the faith that had always been her only bedrock, and she’s never looked back. Never loved again. Sweet Grove finally feels like home, as does the First Street Church, but a small part of Dinah will always wake up wishing she could go back to the man who once loved her more than anything in the world. When Eli leaves home after a life-changing year, he's looking for a fresh start. Figuring Sweet Grove is a safe hour or so from Dinah's orbit in Austin, he takes a part-time job as the photographer at the Sentinel. He even gets himself a date with a teacher at the high school. It’s time to be done orienting his life to a woman who rejected him when he offered her everything. Love has been dying a slow death. Pastor Bernie Olson meets Eli one morning at Mabel's on Maple and asks the new photographer to take a few pictures for the church website. It’ll get him in the pew on Sunday, at least. Eli shows up to help and sees Dinah's profile in his viewfinder. The pain is instant and overwhelming, and if he's not careful, he's going to fall into her gravity again…