Jillian Simpson loves Christmas, but she loves Graham Rogers more. She prays when he returns he will see her for the woman she is and not the little orphan girl he left behind. When that day finally arrives, her hopes are dashed when he doesn’t seem to notice her at all. Graham Rogers used to believe Christmas was magical, but living with his uppity grandfather while attending school in Philadelphia has changed him. Upon his return home, his plans to woo Jillian are ruined when a woman from his past arrives claiming to be his fiancée, and his promised job in a prestigious law firm falls through. With Jillian’s heart breaking, she announces she’s leaving Saint Charles, but will the magic of Christmas be strong enough to bring these two together again before she leaves?