The Cortland crew is back! Lucy and Spencer Clarkson, happily married, are thrown off-course to their happily-ever-after with Spencer heading to the Brooklyn VA in an attempt to coat over his invisible scars. Meanwhile, Levi Barnes is left adrift by the loss of Spencer's navigational assistance at Barnes' Books, which leads him to stumble into meeting Eleanor, a mysterious newcomer to Cortland with a strange past. What kind of person will Levi discover under her masks? When opportunities to heal—for Levi and Eleanor as well as Lucy and Spencer—what paths will they choose? Above all, can God forgive the unforgivable? The broken? The angry at heart?