Radiology tech Miranda Creighton is on call when Bo Sawyer is brought into Sin Hospital with a leg injury he sustained while installing an AC unit. After he and long-time friend Davis Thompson, an ER physician, reveal to Miranda they made a wager that she wouldn’t go out with Bo on a date, Miranda surprises the two by entering into a passionate relationship with both men. Bo and Miranda were betrayed by their ex-spouses, but each is finally ready to take a chance on love again. Davis has always had a thing for Miranda, and is happy to share her with Bo. But the trio’s happily-ever-after is threatened when Miranda’s ex-husband and Bo’s ex-wife come to town for the murder trial of an influential preacher. Not only are Miranda’s and Bo’s exes determined to lie to save the preacher from a conviction, they are also hell bent on tearing the three apart.