Jim Collins spent all of his high school years pining for the star quarterback, Brock Newhouse. Even after graduation, his thoughts often gravitated to the sexy football star and he couldn’t help thinking about what could have been, but never would have happened. When he receives an invitation to his high school reunion and sees that Brock will be attending, he decides he has to see the man one more time. But the night doesn’t go exactly as he imagined, and Jim soon discovers he wasn’t the only man with fantasies during those four years, and he wasn’t the only one who continued to wonder what if.