Archer is tired of being the "boy next door" who gets dumped by his girlfriend and has an embarrassing crush on his boss. But when he researches the possibility of using a dating site while at work, he gets busted by his night editor—the very crush he's trying to move past. Not only does night editor Jorge Ortiz love the idea of Archer trying out a dating site, he loves the idea of him writing about it for the paper even more. Despite his uneasiness, Archer agrees because he's more than ready to meet his next love connection, girl or guy. Tyler is finally moving on after years spent trying to be a good husband. When a day of moving hell leads to a midnight meeting with his cute, geeky neighbor, Tyler thinks it's a stroke of good luck. The two fall into a quick friendship, and Tyler can't help wishing for more. But Archer's uneasy about dating too close to home, and you can't get much closer to home than the same building. Can Tyler break down his barriers, or will Archer always hold him at arm's length?