Tyler Button has always been normal. All the way down to his boring name. After a bad break up leaves him in need of cheering up, he goes to see The Alphas perform live on stage. He loves that band, adores their love songs, and has a huge crush on one of the singers. When two members of the group spot him from the crowd, and find him after the show ends, he thinks things can't get any weirder. Chase Belair and Sam Firestone are ready to fight each other for their mate, until they come to the realization that they're not meant to compete, but work together. There's only a short amount of time to convince the timid human that he belongs with them before the show goes back on the road, but Tyler doesn't seem to think he's worth it to be mated to two men like Sam and Chase. They make it their mission to show him otherwise.