Margins
Supernaturalette book cover 1
Supernaturalette book cover 2
Supernaturalette book cover 3
Supernaturalette
Series · 8 books · 2020-2023

Books in series

Introductions book cover
#1

Introductions

2020

When I’m selected to be the Supernaturalette, I think it’s finally my time to find love. But apparently? This is a special season of the show. Supernaturalette: Fuck Up Edition. Twenty-five men are competing for my hand in marriage. Twenty-five broken, eccentric men. Everything from a man-eating tree to a vegetarian wendigo to a garden gnome. And me, a witch with a penchant for lighting herself—and others—on fire. Let the introductions begin. This is a SERIAL-STYLE reverse harem romance. Each book will be approximately 100 to 200 pages. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader’s group for the contestants. Each installment—including dates and eliminations—will be decided exclusively by the readers. This book will end in a cliff-hanger, so be warned.
First Dates book cover
#2

First Dates

2020

We've been through the introductions... Now, the men have one chance to prove themselves or face elimination. I've chosen a small group of men for my first group date, and one terrifying lumberjack tree for my solo date. But Kyler is more determined than ever to make this the weirdest, strangest season ever of Supernaturalette. Nothing on this show is as it seems, including the men. Meanwhile, I need to discover who murdered the show's costume designer...before the murderer comes after me. Let the first dates begin. This is a SERIAL-STYLE reverse harem romance. Each book will be approximately 100 to 200 pages. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment - including dates and eliminations - will be decided exclusively by the readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned.
Group Outing book cover
#3

Group Outing

2020

You know what sounds like a terrible idea when there is a killer on the loose? A group date where everyone is armed with guns. Paintball guns. But still. My outfit for this massive, twenty-five man group date is to die for. It better be the only thing that is. Let the group outing begin. This is a SERIAL-SYLE reverse harem romance. Each book will be approximately 100 to 200 pages. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment - including dates and eliminations - will be decided exclusively by the readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned.
Game Night book cover
#4

Game Night

2020

First eliminations. First kisses. First attack. What could go wrong? For this group date, I’ll be a participant in a life-sized board game night with some of the contestants I don’t know as well. Will sparks fly? Or will we succumb to the horrors of the games? Combine that with an escape room solo date with a surly cupid, and new secrets will be revealed. Maybe, just maybe, I’ll finish this season of Supernaturalette with a husband and my life. Or a harem. Or maybe we’ll all just end up dead. Let the game night begin. This is a SERIAL-SYLE reverse harem romance. Each book will be approximately 100 to 200 pages. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment - including dates and eliminations - will be decided exclusively by the readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned.
Exes book cover
#5

Exes

2020

Kidnapping, exes, and murder...oh my! It’s becoming clear to me that I bit off way more than I can chew with this show. Not only do I have twenty men vying for my hand, but I also have to deal with vindictive exes, a sadistic cult, and a murderer. Left with no other choice, I decide to do what I should’ve done from the very beginning—offer myself as bait on our next group date and hope that I’m not killed. Did I mention that my only allies are my ex-boyfriend and a guy that may have played a crucial role in my past (if I can remember him, that is)? The joys of being me. Let the meeting of the exes begin. This is a SERIAL-SYLE reverse harem romance. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment - including dates and eliminations - will be decided exclusively by the readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned.
Truth or Dare book cover
#6

Truth or Dare

2021

They say the show must go on, but how can it when one of the competitors is dead and I'm forced to eliminate a couple more? The mysteries surrounding the show and the Red Eyes are expanding every single day, and I'm terrified of what will happen when the director yells cut. Will this be the end of my story? Or has it only just begun? New relationships are forming, old ones are deteriorating for good, and the body count is piling up. The men on the show want to know all of my secrets, and I want to know theirs...even if I discover that one of them is the murderer I've been hunting. Let the game of truth or dare begin. This is a SERIAL-STYLE reverse harem romance. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment - including dates and eliminations - will be decided exclusively by readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned!
Scavenger Hunt book cover
#7

Scavenger Hunt

2022

Things may be heating up between me and the contestants, but I’m more determined than ever to find the murderer before I do something I regret. Like accidentally give him my heart. With eliminations around the corner, I make a last-ditch attempt to uncover the secrets surrounding my kidnapping. Can I handle the truth? And can I handle what I need to do in order to get it? How many pieces do I need to gather to solve this case, and what am I willing to sacrifice in order to do it? Let the scavenger hunt begin. This is a SERIAL-STYLE reverse harem romance. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment—including dates and eliminations—will be decided exclusively by readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned!
Reveals book cover
#8

Reveals

2023

Thanks to the spell Edward performed on me, my missing memories are slowly being returned. Accompanying them is the knowledge that I can't trust anybody. Not even the men who have wormed their way into my heart. Alone, scared, and confused, I must rely on some of the contestants I previously dismissed to help me investigate the string of murders. We're closer than ever to solving this mystery. The question is—will I live long enough to give out my final wand, or will my story end in death? Let the reveals begin. This is a SERIAL-STYLE reverse harem romance. After every release, a poll will be placed in my reader's group for the contestants. Each installment—including dates and eliminations—will be decided exlusively by readers. This book will end in a cliffhanger, so be warned!

Author

Katie May
Author · 70 books

Katie May is a romance writer of numerous genres! She writes everything from horror to fantasy to contemporary. #whychoose She has a gorgeous tabby cat who she adores, and she’s obsessed with coffee and horror movies.

548 Market St PMB 65688, San Francisco California 94104-5401 USA
© 2025 Paratext Inc. All rights reserved