Bethany has led a spoiled life, thanks to her older sister, Levinia, who always did everything for her while raising her. Being a domestic failure, Bethany decides it's time she learned those skills so she can find a husband. With the help of the Widow Yoder, Bethany talks her father into re-opening her mother's bakery that has sat vacant since her passing. She quickly finds out that baking is not as easy as it looks. Regretting his decision to let his daughter run the bakery, her father enlists the help of Benjamin, Miriam's older brother, to teach Bethany the skills she needs to make a success of the business. Insulted by her father's lack of confidence in her, and feeling threatened by Benjamin's perfection when it comes to baking, Bethany sets out to sabotage him, hoping her father will fire him. Will her new skills as a baker enable her to get the husband she has her eye on, or will Benjamin sabotage her efforts?