Small college town Hopeton is gaining attention for the number of menage and poly relationships in the town. A flurry of businesses hosting and celebrating alternative weddings is growing. As the town enjoys pies from the new Thankful Cafe for Thanksgiving, many singles in the town discover that they, too, are finding happiness with two or more people. Renee is enjoying the growing interest in holiday pies from her new Thankful Cafe. She doesn't have time for the distraction of her interest in three attractive regulars in the café. Phil, Dominic and Alan have been friends since grade school. Now that Phil is back in town, it seems like they might finally be able to explore the idea of finding the perfect woman for all of them. Alan feels sure that delicious Renee is the answer to their dream.