Faye thinks Hattie’s a suspect. Chloe thinks she’s a kindred soul. Only Hattie knows for sure! Best friends Faye Crane and Chloe ‘Mama’ Rossi are deep into another historic building preservation project in the tiny village of Morelville. Money is tight and it gets even tighter when the rare coins one of their prospective donors, Bridget Novak, was going to auction off to benefit the project come up missing. Written out of a hit sitcom when she’s suspected of maliciously using witchcraft to further her career, Althea Dwyer, returns to using her given name, Hattie Novak, and moves in with her aunt Bridget to lick her wounds and kick off her next move. When Bridget’s oldest friend Selma confides she’s experienced coin thefts too, Hattie sticks her nose into the investigation on behalf of her aunt and her friend. The local sheriff warns off all the ladies as rare coins continue to disappear and bodies pile up, but the trio each have their reasons for wanting to see the coins returned and justice done. They don’t take orders from Faye’s eldest child too seriously. They won’t stop until the coins are recovered, a murderer is in jail, and the restoration can continue.