When Mary Stoltzfus opened her bakery in Faith’s Creek, she expected a fresh start—not whispers of scandal and doubt. Eli Fischer is a gentle wanderer, searching for roots in the warmth of a welcoming community. When he agrees to help Mary with her fledgling bakery, friendship blossoms—and perhaps something deeper. Yet shadows from Eli’s past cast doubts in Faith’s Creek, threatening their chance at happiness. With the encouragement of the spirited quilting circle and wisdom from Bishop Amos Beiler, Mary, and Eli must learn to forgive past wounds, embrace trust, and savor the simple joys that faith and friendship bring. Filled with heartwarming Amish traditions, gentle romance, and enduring lessons of forgiveness, Faith in the Frosting invites you into a charming community you'll wish was your own. Can Mary and Eli rise above whispers of the past, or will mistrust spoil their sweetest chance at love? Perfect for fans of Wanda Brunstetter, Beverly Lewis, and readers who cherish wholesome stories about second chances, quilting bees, and the comforting embrace of faith.