Festive joy seems in short supply this holiday season. When a rival appears for her Christmas cookies, Abigail is faced with ruin. Abigail Mast supports her family by selling her cookies in the market. Christmas is her biggest time of year, but disaster was soon to strike. The Troyer family had their sad past, which they had hoped to run from by moving to the new community where they started a bakery. Amos Troyer was disappointed in the change of character in his parents. Now he was even more disappointed in their approach to the pretty young Amish girl they regarded as a competitor. This Christmas, a young Amish girl prays for a Christmas miracle. A young Amish man is prepared to risk everything to do what he thinks is right. Will the magic of Christmas bring two hearts together as one?