The sequel to The Little Lost Amish Boy; the saga continues… Mary had given her baby son Able up and allowed Ruth and Samuel to legally adopt him while still enjoying almost daily contact with him in the Amish community. Gott had been gut to Mary, bringing Amos into her life. Amos and Mary had been married for five years and Gott had not yet seen fit to bless their union with a boppli. Tragedy strikes the Amish community with the death of Mr. Hertzler and then the schoolmistress, Emily. It follows that Mary is soon rewarded with a full time post at the school house, but the childless widow Ellen Hertzler is not coping well with her loss. The community was soon to feel the brunt of her concept of a solution to her problem. Is Gott punishing Mary for the choices she made during and immediately following Rumspringa? Will little Able pay the debt for the mistakes of the older generation? Can the love between Amos and Mary endure these hardships?