After spending years together at the Willoughby Hall Home for Children, Cat, Josie, and Becka face the prospects of being separated when the Morgans arrive looking for a daughter to adopt.

The oldest orphans at the Willoughby Hall Home for Children, Cat, Josie, and Becka are delighted to all be adopted by Annie and Ben Morgan, only to discover that learning how to be part of a family can also be difficult.

Becka bends over backwards to become the most popular girl in school, making life miserable for herself and her new adoptive sisters

Green Falls Junior High is gearing up for the first dance of the year, and Josie, Becka, and Cat Morgan have lots to do before they're ready. Cat and Becka are busy making plans for their dates, but they keep trying to push Josie and Red together. When Red finally asks Josie to the dance, Josie's sure it wasn't his idea. But should that keep her from saying yes?

When Heather steals Cat's boyfriend, Cat decides to get even by buying the expensive dress Heather had wanted, but then Cat must find a job in order to pay for it

Determined to raise her pal Marla's spirits, Cat agrees to help her win the Homecoming Queen crown, but when she herself is nominated, it becomes a bitter popularity contest that could ruin their friendship